Signs Your Relationship Is in Trouble: The Early Warnings
Relationship Health · · 9 min read
Short answer
The earliest signs your relationship is in trouble are usually private: you think about leaving more often, imagine a future without your partner, and stop raising problems. Research on marital instability finds these thoughts tend to come before talk and action. A slow slide in satisfaction and quiet withdrawal are stronger warnings than the occasional loud fight.
By the Compatify Editorial Team · Sources checked . Science-informed self-reflection, not clinical advice. How we write and check guides.
It is not the fight that tells you. The fight was on Saturday and it was the usual one. What tells you is Tuesday night, when your partner is in the next room and you catch yourself scrolling one-bedroom rentals on your phone. You close the app before you have quite admitted why you opened it. Nothing has happened. Nobody has said anything. But a thought has started to visit, and it has started to stay a little longer each time.
Most people expect trouble to announce itself with something loud: an affair, a blow-up, a door slammed. Research on how relationships come apart suggests the opposite. The early warnings are quiet, often private, and easy to explain away, which is exactly why they are worth knowing.
What are the signs a relationship is in trouble?
The signs a relationship is in trouble are the early steps toward leaving it: thinking about ending it more often, picturing a future without your partner, talking to friends about leaving, a steady decline in satisfaction, and a shift from raising problems to quietly letting things slide. Sociologists Alan Booth, David Johnson and John Edwards called this cluster marital instability, a propensity to dissolve a relationship, and in 1983 they published a way to measure it. Their insight was that instability is different from unhappiness. Plenty of unhappy couples stay, and some fairly happy ones leave. What predicts leaving is the thinking and acting that leans toward the door.
Why do thoughts of leaving matter so much?
Because they usually come first. Booth and his colleagues found that relationships tend to come apart as a process rather than an event, with attitudes changing before behaviour does. In a 1985 follow-up in the Journal of Family Issues, the same team tracked couples over time and reported that people who scored high on their instability measure were far more likely to divorce or separate than people who scored low. Divorce became more likely as private thoughts gave way to overt steps. John Gottman and Robert Levenson described something similar in 1992, a cascade in which low satisfaction leads to seriously considering separation, then to separation itself. The order matters: if you catch the thought early, there is still a lot of road before anything is decided.
| Step | What it looks like | What it means | What helps now |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dissatisfaction that does not lift | Good weeks no longer reset the mood | The baseline has moved, not just the weather | Name it to yourself, and to your partner, in plain words |
| Thoughts of leaving | Imagining life alone, wondering if you would be happier | The idea is rehearsing itself | Ask what the thought is protecting you from |
| Talking about leaving | Telling a friend you might go, half joking | The thought has moved outside your head | Have the conversation with your partner first |
| Preparing to leave | Separate plans, separate money, rentals saved on your phone | Exit is becoming practical | Decide deliberately, ideally with a counsellor |
What are the quiet warning signs people miss?
Neglect is the warning sign people miss most, because it looks like peace. In 1982 Caryl Rusbult, Isabella Zembrodt and Lawrence Gunn described four ways people respond when they are dissatisfied with a relationship, borrowing the economist Albert Hirschman's terms and adding one of their own. Two of the responses are active and two are passive; two help the relationship and two harm it.
| Response | Active or passive | Effect on the relationship | Looks like |
|---|---|---|---|
| Voice | Active | Constructive | Raising the problem, suggesting a change, asking for help together |
| Loyalty | Passive | Constructive | Waiting it out, staying hopeful, giving the benefit of the doubt |
| Neglect | Passive | Destructive | Letting things slide, spending less time together, going cold |
| Exit | Active | Destructive | Separating, threatening to leave, or actively ending it |
A loud couple who argue in the voice column can be in better shape than a quiet couple who have both drifted into neglect. If your arguments have stopped, ask whether things got better or whether one of you stopped trying. The conflict-styles guide explains why the same fight keeps returning, and why that is not always the worst sign.
Is fighting a sign your relationship is in trouble?
Not on its own; how you fight matters more than how often. Gottman and Levenson followed couples over four years and divided them by the balance of positive to negative behaviour in their conversations. Couples whose interactions tipped negative showed more stubbornness and withdrawal, more defensiveness, less positive emotion and lower satisfaction, and they were at greater risk of separating. Frequent conflict with warmth and repair is a different thing from frequent conflict that leaves each of you more guarded than before. If your fights rarely end with a repair, the guide to making up after a fight is the place to start.
Does it matter if satisfaction is slowly falling?
Yes, and the direction can matter as much as the level. Justin Lavner and Thomas Bradbury followed newlywed spouses over their first four years and found that most spouses started out moderately to highly satisfied and declined only a little. A smaller group, roughly one in five, showed substantial declines, and those spouses were far more likely to have divorced within ten years. The lesson for any couple is to compare this year with last year, not this week with last week. A relationship that is moderately happy and steady is in a different place from one that is moderately happy and sliding.
What should you do if you notice the warning signs?
Treat a warning sign as information, not a verdict. Most of the steps above are reversible, and the earlier you name one, the more options you have.
- Write down which signs you recognise and how long each has been there. Months is a pattern; days is a mood.
- Notice whether you have moved from voice into neglect. If you have stopped raising things, raise one small thing this week.
- Tell your partner what you have noticed in yourself, not what is wrong with them: I have been feeling distant and I do not want to.
- Look at the trend: compare how you feel now with how you felt a year ago, not with last Saturday.
- If thoughts of leaving have become plans, see a couples counsellor before you decide, together if possible and alone if not.
If the harder question is whether the relationship was ever working well, the guide to a healthy relationship describes what healthy looks like, area by area, which is the other half of this picture.
Where does the idea of relationship instability come from?
For most of the twentieth century, researchers studied relationships mainly through happiness and adjustment, asking how satisfied couples were. In 1970 the economist Albert Hirschman published Exit, Voice, and Loyalty, about how people respond when a firm or an organisation declines, and in 1982 Rusbult and her colleagues applied those ideas to romantic relationships and added neglect. Around the same time, Booth, Johnson and Edwards, working on a long-running national survey of married Americans that began in 1980, argued that satisfaction was not enough to predict who would separate. Their 1983 measure of marital instability asked about thoughts and steps toward leaving instead. Gottman and Levenson's laboratory studies added the behaviour of couples in conversation, and later work such as Lavner and Bradbury's moved attention to how satisfaction changes over time.
How do you check your own relationship's warning signs?
Measure the trend rather than the mood. Compatify's Relationship Indicators Test looks at five areas: stability and commitment, instability thoughts, conflict frequency, satisfaction trajectory, and loyalty versus exit. Together they show whether your relationship is steady, under strain, or showing early signs of instability, and which area is driving it. Take it on your own first, so the answers are honestly yours. Then compare it with your partner's result, if they are willing, and talk about the area where you differ most.
The framework behind this
Booth, Johnson and Edwards's 1983 paper in the Journal of Marriage and the Family introduced the measurement of marital instability, and their 1985 follow-up with Lynn White in the Journal of Family Issues showed that it predicted later divorce and separation. Rusbult, Zembrodt and Gunn's 1982 paper in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology supplied the four responses to dissatisfaction. Gottman and Levenson's 1992 study in the same journal supplied the findings on negative interaction and the cascade toward separation. Lavner and Bradbury's 2010 study in the Journal of Marriage and Family showed why the trajectory of satisfaction matters. Compatify's test is grounded in the Marital Instability Index (Booth, Johnson and Edwards). It uses its own questions rather than the index's items, and adds conflict, satisfaction trajectory and loyalty versus exit. It is science-informed self-reflection, not a clinical evaluation.
What this cannot tell you
A result describes how you see your relationship now. It cannot tell you whether to stay or go, what your partner is thinking, or whether a hard stretch will pass. Research findings describe groups of couples, not your couple. It also cannot see danger. If you feel afraid of your partner, or a relationship involves control, threats or violence, that is not a warning sign to monitor: safety comes first. Contact 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732 for confidential support around the clock, Lifeline on 13 11 14 if you are in crisis, or 000 in an emergency.
Common questions
- What are the early signs a relationship is in trouble?
- Thinking about leaving more often, picturing a future without your partner, talking to friends about ending it, a steady slide in satisfaction over months, and a shift from raising problems to quietly letting things go.
- Is it normal to think about leaving a relationship?
- An occasional passing thought is common. The warning sign is a thought that returns often, stays longer each time, and begins to turn into talk or practical plans, because research finds instability builds in that order.
- Is constant fighting a sign of a failing relationship?
- Not by itself. Research by Gottman and Levenson found that the balance of positive to negative behaviour mattered more than conflict alone. Fights that end in repair are different from fights that leave both partners more guarded.
- Can a relationship in trouble be saved?
- Often, especially when the signs are noticed early. Most warning signs are thoughts and habits rather than final decisions, and raising problems openly, alone or with a couples counsellor, gives a relationship more options than quiet withdrawal.
- What is the difference between a rough patch and real trouble?
- Time and direction. A rough patch has a cause and lifts when the cause passes. Real trouble shows up as a steady decline in satisfaction, persistent thoughts of leaving, or one partner going quiet and disengaged for months.
Sources
- Booth, A., Johnson, D. and Edwards, J. N. (1983). Measuring marital instability. Journal of Marriage and the Family.
- Booth, A., Johnson, D. R., White, L. K. and Edwards, J. N. (1985). Predicting divorce and permanent separation. Journal of Family Issues.
- Rusbult, C. E., Zembrodt, I. M. and Gunn, L. K. (1982). Exit, voice, loyalty, and neglect: responses to dissatisfaction in romantic involvements. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
- Gottman, J. M. and Levenson, R. W. (1992). Marital processes predictive of later dissolution: behavior, physiology, and health. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
- Lavner, J. A. and Bradbury, T. N. (2010). Patterns of change in marital satisfaction over the newlywed years. Journal of Marriage and Family.