The Four Horsemen in Relationships and Their Antidotes
Communication · · 9 min read
Short answer
The four horsemen are John Gottman's name for four conflict habits his research linked to unhappy relationships and divorce: criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling. Each has an antidote: a gentle start-up, appreciation, taking responsibility and calming your body before you continue. Contempt, which Gottman calls the most damaging, is the one to stop first.
By the Compatify Editorial Team · Sources checked . Science-informed self-reflection, not clinical advice. How we write and check guides.
You mention, carefully, that the bins went out late again. It comes back as: you always find something. You say that is not fair, you are the one who actually remembers things in this house, and you hear the edge in your own voice. Your partner rolls their eyes. Then they pick up their phone and stop answering altogether. The whole exchange took less than a minute, and it contained every one of the four habits that relationship researchers worry about most.
The psychologist John Gottman spent decades filming couples while they argued, and he gave those four habits a deliberately ominous name: the four horsemen. The name is memorable, but the useful part is less dramatic. Each horseman has a specific antidote, a small change in what you say or do that interrupts it, and none of them requires either of you to stop disagreeing.
What are the four horsemen in a relationship?
The four horsemen are criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling. Criticism attacks your partner's character instead of a specific behaviour. Contempt speaks from a position of superiority, through mockery, sarcasm, eye-rolling or name-calling. Defensiveness answers a complaint with a counter-attack or an excuse. Stonewalling is shutting down, going blank or leaving while your partner is still talking. Gottman's research was done with couples, but the four are easy to recognise between parents and adult children, siblings and close friends too.
| Horseman | What it sounds like | Why it hurts | The antidote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Criticism | You never think about anyone but yourself | It turns one problem into a verdict on who your partner is | A gentle start-up: describe the situation and what you need |
| Contempt | Eye-rolling, mockery, oh, poor you | It tells your partner they are beneath you | Building a habit of appreciation and respect, out loud |
| Defensiveness | Well, you never told me, and anyway you do it too | It refuses the complaint, so nothing gets solved | Taking responsibility, even for a small part of it |
| Stonewalling | Silence, a blank face, the phone, the closing door | Your partner is left talking to no one | Calling a pause, calming your body, then coming back |
Why is contempt the most damaging of the four?
Gottman has described contempt as the strongest single predictor of divorce he found, and it is easy to see why it lands harder than the other three. Criticism says you did something wrong. Contempt says you are something lesser. It usually arrives through the face and the tone as much as the words: the eye-roll, the sneer, the sarcastic thanks for your help. Contempt also tends to grow from resentment that has been left unspoken for a long time, which is why the antidote is slow rather than instant. You rebuild a habit of noticing what your partner does well, and of saying it. If contempt has become the normal temperature between you, the guide to feeling respected looks at what respect looks like day to day.
What is the difference between a complaint and criticism?
A complaint is about a behaviour; a criticism is about a person. I was worried when you did not call is a complaint. You are so selfish, you never think to call is a criticism. The first gives your partner something they can fix. The second gives them something to defend, which is why criticism so often invites defensiveness in return. Gottman calls the alternative a gentle start-up: describe what happened without blame, say how you feel, and ask for something specific.
- Instead of you never help, try I am exhausted and I need you to do the bath tonight.
- Instead of you are always late, try I felt embarrassed waiting on my own; can we leave ten minutes earlier next time?
- Instead of why are you like this, try can we talk about what happened at dinner?
Why do people stonewall, and is it the same as taking a break?
Stonewalling is usually not indifference. More often it is overwhelm. Gottman's lab measured heart rate during arguments and found that some partners became so physiologically aroused that they could no longer take in what was being said, a state he called flooding. Shutting down is how many people cope with it. The difference between stonewalling and a healthy break is what you say and whether you come back. Gottman suggests a pause of at least twenty minutes, spent doing something calming rather than rehearsing your case, followed by a return to the conversation. Saying I am too flooded to listen well, give me half an hour, is a break. Walking out in silence is a stonewall. If your body takes over in arguments, the nervous system regulation guide covers what is happening and what helps.
How do you stop the four horsemen?
You stop them one conversation at a time, by catching your own horseman rather than your partner's. Trying to point out the other person's contempt mid-argument usually becomes a fifth horseman. These habits help:
- Learn the four names together at a calm moment, so either of you can say that was criticism without starting a new fight.
- Start hard conversations with a situation and a need, not a summary of your partner's character.
- When you feel the urge to roll your eyes, treat it as a sign that something unsaid needs saying, and say it plainly later.
- Find the part of the complaint that is true, even if it is small, and own that part first.
- Agree on a pause signal, and agree that the person who calls the pause is the one who restarts the conversation.
- Make a repair early, an apology, a joke, a touch, before the argument hardens.
Repair is the thread running through all four antidotes, and the guide to repair attempts covers what a good one sounds like. If your arguments follow a chase-and-retreat shape, with criticism on one side and stonewalling on the other, the demand-withdraw guide explains that loop in detail.
Do the four horsemen really predict divorce?
They are linked to it, but the famous accuracy figures need care. In a 1992 study, Gottman and Robert Levenson observed 73 married couples in 1983 and again in 1987. The couples at higher risk of separating showed more negative emotion, more defensiveness, and more stubbornness and withdrawal than couples who stayed steady. A 14-year study the pair published in 2000 added an important twist. Negative emotion during conflict predicted divorces that came early in a marriage, while the absence of positive emotion, in everyday conversation as well as in arguments, predicted divorces that came much later. Avoiding the horsemen is only half the job; warmth matters too.
That 2000 paper reported that its model predicted divorce with 93 per cent accuracy, and figures like that travelled widely. Other researchers pushed back. Scott Stanley, Thomas Bradbury and Howard Markman argued in 2000 that Gottman's newlywed study had drawn strong recommendations from correlational data and a non-random sample. In 2001 Richard Heyman and Amy Slep showed that when divorce prediction equations are tested on new data, a step called cross-validation, their accuracy drops sharply. The fair summary is that the four horsemen are well-observed warning signs in conflict, not a machine that can tell you whether a particular relationship will last.
Where did the four horsemen idea come from?
The name borrows from the Book of Revelation, where four horsemen arrive to announce the end of the world. Gottman began observing couples in the 1970s, and with Levenson he built a University of Washington laboratory in 1986 where couples discussed a disagreement while researchers recorded their heart rates and coded their facial expressions and what they said. In 1994 Gottman set out the four behaviours in What Predicts Divorce?, an academic book, and described them for a general audience the same year in Why Marriages Succeed or Fail. His 1999 book with Nan Silver, The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work, made them familiar to couples and counsellors far beyond the research world. The antidotes were developed later in that work and in the Gottman Institute's training for therapists, as the research moved from describing what goes wrong to teaching couples what to do instead.
How do you find out which horsemen show up in your own arguments?
Your partner's horseman is often easier to spot than your own. Compatify's Communication & Conflict Deep Dive is built on Gottman's conflict research and measures the four horsemen directly, as criticism versus complaint, contempt and respect, defensiveness, and stonewalling and withdrawal. It sets them alongside eleven other areas, from listening and validation to repair and de-escalation, so you see the antidotes you already use as well as the habits that hurt. Take it, ask your partner to take it, and compare which horsemen each of you brings.
The framework behind this
Gottman and Levenson's 1992 study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology linked defensiveness and withdrawal in conflict to later separation. Gottman's What Predicts Divorce? set out the four horsemen in 1994, and The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work, with Nan Silver, brought them and their remedies to couples in 1999. Gottman and Levenson's 2000 paper in the Journal of Marriage and Family separated the early and late paths to divorce. Stanley, Bradbury and Markman's 2000 critique and Heyman and Slep's 2001 paper on cross-validation, both in the same journal, set the limits on what the prediction figures mean. Compatify's test draws on Gottman's conflict research. It is science-informed self-reflection, not a clinical evaluation.
What this cannot tell you
A result describes your conflict habits as you report them. It cannot tell you whether your relationship will last, why your partner reacts the way they do, or whether a long-running fight can be solved. Spotting a horseman is not the same as being in a bad relationship; Gottman's couples who stayed together showed the four as well, just less often. The four horsemen describe ordinary conflict between two people who can both speak freely. Contempt that comes with threats, intimidation, control over money or friends, or fear of what the other person will do is not a communication habit, and safety comes first. In Australia, 1800RESPECT is on 1800 737 732 at any hour, and anyone in immediate danger should call 000.
Common questions
- What are the four horsemen of a relationship?
- They are criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling, the four conflict habits John Gottman's research linked most closely to unhappiness and divorce. Each has an antidote: a gentle start-up, appreciation, taking responsibility and calming down before you continue.
- Which of the four horsemen is the worst?
- Gottman singles out contempt, because it treats a partner as beneath you rather than objecting to something they did. It is also the slowest to undo, because the antidote is a steady habit of appreciation rather than a single change of words.
- Is stonewalling the same as giving someone the silent treatment?
- They can look alike, but stonewalling is often driven by overwhelm rather than punishment. The fix is the same either way: name that you need a pause, take time to calm down, and come back to the conversation when you said you would.
- Can a relationship recover from the four horsemen?
- It can. The horsemen also appear in couples who stay together; what matters is how often, and whether repair follows. Couples who learn the antidotes and use them early can change the pattern, and a couples counsellor can help when it feels stuck.
- What is the antidote to defensiveness?
- Taking responsibility for part of the problem, even a small part. Saying you are right, I did forget, gives your partner something to work with, where a counter-attack or an excuse simply restarts the argument.
Sources
- Gottman, J. M. and Levenson, R. W. (1992). Marital processes predictive of later dissolution: behavior, physiology, and health. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
- Gottman, J. M. (1994). What Predicts Divorce? The Relationship Between Marital Processes and Marital Outcomes. Lawrence Erlbaum.
- Gottman, J. M. (1994). Why Marriages Succeed or Fail. Simon and Schuster.
- Gottman, J. M. and Silver, N. (1999). The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work. Crown.
- Gottman, J. M. and Levenson, R. W. (2000). The timing of divorce: predicting when a couple will divorce over a 14-year period. Journal of Marriage and Family.
- Stanley, S. M., Bradbury, T. N. and Markman, H. J. (2000). Structural flaws in the bridge from basic research on marriage to interventions for couples. Journal of Marriage and Family.
- Heyman, R. E. and Slep, A. M. S. (2001). The hazards of predicting divorce without crossvalidation. Journal of Marriage and Family.