How to Make Up After a Fight: The Steps of a Real Repair
Relationship Health · · 8 min read
Short answer
To make up after a fight, wait until you are both calm, then reach out, own your part without adding a but, listen to how it felt for the other person, and agree one thing that will change. Repair is not about deciding who was right. It is about making it safe for both of you to come back together.
By the Compatify Editorial Team · Sources checked . Science-informed self-reflection, not clinical advice. How we write and check guides.
The fight was about the dishwasher, technically. It is now eleven at night. One of you is in bed scrolling, and the other is on the couch watching something neither of you will remember. The house is very quiet. Both of you want this to be over, and both of you are waiting for the other one to walk into the room first, because going first feels like admitting you lost.
Every couple fights. John Gottman's research suggests that what happens after an argument matters more than how often couples argue. Making up is a skill, and like most relationship skills it has a few steps that work and a few habits that quietly make things worse. Few of us are ever taught either.
What does it mean to repair after an argument?
Repair after an argument is anything either partner does to reconnect and stop the tension from escalating or lingering: a softened tone, a joke, a touch, an apology, an I see your point, or an invitation to try again. Repair can happen during a fight as well as after it. It does not require settling the disagreement. Many couples repair successfully and still disagree about the dishwasher. What repair restores is the sense that you are on the same side, which is what makes the actual problem solvable later.
Why is it so hard to make up after a fight?
Because two people are often trying to repair in opposite directions. Andrew Christensen and Christopher Heavey studied the demand-withdraw pattern, in which one partner pushes to talk about a problem and the other pulls away. They found the roles depend partly on whose issue is on the table: the person who wants something to change tends to press, and the person who would rather keep things as they are tends to retreat. After a fight the same split shows up. One of you wants to talk it through now; the other needs space first. Each sees the other's move as making things worse. The demand-withdraw guide explains the loop in more detail.
Bodies matter too. John Gottman's research describes flooding, the state where your heart is racing and you are too physically stirred up to listen. Repair attempts made while one partner is flooded often fail, not because they are bad attempts, but because nobody can take them in. That is why the first step is almost always to calm down.
What are the steps to make up after a fight?
- Calm down first. Take a real break, long enough for your heart rate to settle, and say when you will come back so it does not feel like abandonment.
- Reach out, whoever goes first. A simple can we try again is enough. Going first is not losing.
- Own your part, specifically and without a but. I was sharp with you and that was not fair is a repair. I was sharp, but you started it is a second round.
- Listen to how it felt for them before explaining how it felt for you. Ask what the worst part was.
- Share your side briefly, as feelings rather than charges: I felt dismissed, not you always dismiss me.
- Agree one small thing that will change, then let the conversation end. Not every fight needs a full resolution tonight.
- Reconnect physically or warmly if you both want to: a hug, a cup of tea, sitting together. The body needs to know it is over too.
What makes an apology actually work?
Taking responsibility, more than anything else. Roy Lewicki, Beth Polin and Robert Lount tested six parts of an apology: expressing regret, explaining what went wrong, acknowledging responsibility, declaring repentance, offering to repair, and asking for forgiveness. Apologies with more of the parts worked better, and acknowledging responsibility mattered most, followed by an offer to repair. Asking for forgiveness mattered least. In a relationship, that means I am sorry you were upset does very little, while I did this, I can see it hurt, and here is what I will do differently does a lot. The apology guide goes further into wording that lands.
What are the different repair styles?
Many people lean on one or two ways of making up, often ones they learned growing up. Each style can work. Each can also backfire, especially when it is used on a partner who repairs differently.
| Repair style | What it looks like | Works when | Backfires when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reassuring | We are okay, I love you | Your partner fears the fight means the relationship is in danger | It skips past the actual problem |
| Explaining | Here is what I meant | There was a genuine misunderstanding | It sounds like a defence before the hurt is heard |
| Apologising | I am sorry, that was on me | You own something specific | It is used to end the conversation quickly |
| Problem-solving | Let us work out a system | Both of you feel heard already | It arrives before the feelings are dealt with |
| Humour | A shared joke that breaks the tension | Both people are ready to soften | One person is still hurt and feels mocked |
| Seeking closeness | A hug, sitting together, staying near | Your partner wants connection to feel safe | Your partner needs space first |
| Protecting space | I need an hour, then let us talk | You give a return time and keep it | Space has no end and becomes the silent treatment |
| Shutting down | Going quiet, leaving, refusing to engage | Rarely, except as a brief pause | Almost always, because the other person is left alone with it |
What if your partner will not make up?
Make a clear, low-pressure offer, then give it time. Say that you want to reconnect when they are ready, and ask what would help. Some people need longer to come down from a fight, and pushing harder usually extends it. If days go by, or silence is being used as punishment, that is a different problem from repair style, and worth raising at a calm moment, or with a counsellor. For the moment-to-moment skill of repairing during a conflict, the repair attempts guide is the companion to this one.
Where does the idea of relationship repair come from?
Some of the earliest evidence came from babies. In 1978 the developmental psychologist Edward Tronick and colleagues described the still-face experiment, in which a mother stops responding to her infant for a short time, and the baby works hard to re-engage her and becomes distressed when she stays still. Tronick's later work argued that ordinary interactions between parents and infants fall out of sync often and are repaired just as often, and that this cycle of rupture and repair is how trust is built.
From the 1980s onward, John Gottman's observational research on couples applied the same idea to adults. He popularised the term repair attempt and argued, in The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work, that whether repair attempts succeed is one of the best signs of a relationship's future. Janice Driver and Gottman later showed in newlyweds that small everyday moments of playfulness and enthusiasm were linked to more humour and affection during conflict, which suggests that repair is built long before the fight starts.
How do you find your own repair style?
Compatify's Relationship Repair Style Test explores what you tend to do after conflict, disconnection or emotional friction in love. It looks at how quickly you move toward repair, whether you reassure, explain, apologise, problem-solve, use humour, seek closeness, protect space or shut down, and how well you respond when your partner reaches out first. The result shows your default repair style, your stress triggers and the habits that make reconnection easier or harder. Take it with your partner and compare: you may find you have been repairing in two different ways.
The framework behind this
John Gottman and Nan Silver's The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work supplied the idea of repair attempts and flooding. Andrew Christensen and Christopher Heavey's 1990 paper in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology supplied the account of the demand-withdraw pattern. Roy Lewicki, Beth Polin and Robert Lount's 2016 paper in Negotiation and Conflict Management Research supplied the six parts of an apology and which matter most. Janice Driver and John Gottman's 2004 paper in Family Process linked everyday moments to warmth during conflict. Edward Tronick and colleagues' 1978 paper supplied the still-face experiment at the root of rupture and repair. Compatify's test is its own reflection tool, informed by Gottman's work on repair attempts, attachment theory and demand-withdraw patterns, and it is not an adaptation of any published scale. It is science-informed self-reflection, not a clinical evaluation.
What this cannot tell you
A result describes your own habits after conflict. It cannot tell you what your partner experiences, who was right in a particular fight, or whether a relationship will last. Repair advice also assumes that conflict between you is safe. If arguments involve threats, intimidation, being afraid of your partner, or any physical harm, the priority is safety, not making up. You can call 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732 at any hour, or 000 if you are in immediate danger.
Common questions
- How long should you wait to make up after a fight?
- Long enough for both of you to feel physically calm, which for many people means a real break rather than a few minutes. Agree when you will come back, so the pause does not turn into the silent treatment.
- Who should apologise first after a fight?
- Whoever is ready first. Going first is not admitting you were wrong about everything; it is choosing the relationship over the scoreboard. Over time it helps if both of you take turns being the one who reaches out.
- Is it okay to go to bed angry?
- Sometimes it is better than forcing a resolution while exhausted or upset. A short repair, such as I love you and we will sort this tomorrow, followed by a real conversation the next day, is often the wisest option.
- What should you say to make up after a fight?
- Own your part specifically, without a but, and ask how it felt for them. Something like I was sharp with you, I can see it hurt, and I want to do better is far more effective than a general sorry.
- What if we make up but keep having the same fight?
- Then the repair is working but the underlying issue is not being solved. Once you are both calm, book a separate time to tackle the recurring problem itself, and look at the pattern behind it rather than the latest example.
Sources
- Gottman, J. M. and Silver, N. (1999). The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work. Crown.
- Christensen, A. and Heavey, C. L. (1990). Gender and social structure in the demand/withdraw pattern of marital conflict. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
- Lewicki, R. J., Polin, B. and Lount, R. B. (2016). An exploration of the structure of effective apologies. Negotiation and Conflict Management Research.
- Driver, J. L. and Gottman, J. M. (2004). Daily marital interactions and positive affect during marital conflict among newlywed couples. Family Process.
- Tronick, E., Als, H., Adamson, L., Wise, S. and Brazelton, T. B. (1978). The infant's response to entrapment between contradictory messages in face-to-face interaction. Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry.