Signs of a Toxic Relationship, and When It Is Abuse
Relationship Health · · Updated · 9 min read
Short answer
Toxic is not a clinical term. It can describe one of two things: an unhealthy relationship, with harmful patterns both people can own and change, or a controlling one, where one person uses fear, isolation or threats to dominate the other. The clearest sign of the second is being afraid of your partner. If so, safety comes first.
By the Compatify Editorial Team · Sources checked . Science-informed self-reflection, not clinical advice. How we write and check guides.
It is late, the argument is over, and you are lying awake replaying it. You are not sure any more who started it, or whether you were unreasonable, or whether this is just what relationships are like. A friend once used the word toxic about the two of you and you defended your partner. Tonight you typed the word into a search bar yourself.
Toxic gets used for almost everything now, from a bad week of bickering to a relationship someone is afraid to leave. Those are very different situations, and they need very different responses. The useful question is not whether your relationship deserves the word. It is which of the two things the word can mean is happening to you.
What is a toxic relationship?
A toxic relationship is a popular, not clinical, name for a relationship that repeatedly leaves one or both people feeling worse about themselves, more anxious or more alone than they did before it. Under the label sit two different situations. An unhealthy relationship has harmful patterns, such as contempt, constant criticism or shutting down, that both people take part in and both could change. A controlling or abusive relationship is one where one person uses fear, intimidation, isolation or threats to dominate the other. The Queensland Government describes coercive control as a pattern of abusive behaviours over time that hurt, humiliate, isolate, frighten or threaten another person in order to control or dominate them. The word toxic is also used about families, friendships and workplaces, and the same distinction applies there.
What are the signs of a toxic relationship?
The signs fall into two groups, and the second group matters more. Signs that a relationship has become unhealthy can include:
- Arguments that go round in circles and never get resolved.
- Criticism of who your partner is, rather than complaints about what they did.
- Eye-rolling, mockery or sarcasm that has become the normal tone.
- One or both of you shutting down, going silent or leaving mid-conversation.
- Keeping score, with every kindness or failure tallied for later.
- Feeling lonely when you are together.
Signs that a relationship may be controlling can include: being afraid of how your partner will react; checking your phone, messages or location; deciding who you see, or making seeing friends and family so costly that you stop; controlling money or access to it; threats, including threats to leave, to self-harm or to hurt pets or children; and making you feel that you are the problem, so you doubt your own memory of what happened. If you recognise any of the second list, read the section on safety below before anything else.
Toxic vs unhealthy relationship: what is the difference?
The difference is power and fear. In an unhealthy relationship both people can speak, disagree and say no, even if they do it badly. In a controlling one, one person's freedom is shrinking.
| Area | Unhealthy | Controlling or abusive |
|---|---|---|
| Arguments | Both people get heated, both can push back | One person sets the terms and the other learns to avoid triggering them |
| Fear | Frustration, hurt, dread of another fight | Fear of what the other person will do |
| Your world | Friends, family and money stay your own | Your contact, movements or money are watched or limited |
| After a fight | Both can apologise and attempt repair | Apologies may come, then the pattern returns |
| Who changes | Both people own part of the pattern | Responsibility sits with the person using control |
| What helps | Better habits, honest talks, couples counselling | A specialist family violence service first |
How do you know if a relationship is toxic or abusive?
Ask whether one person's fear or loss of freedom is part of the pattern, because that is what separates abuse from a relationship that is simply going badly. In 1995 the sociologist Michael Johnson argued that what researchers were calling domestic violence was really two different things: occasional violence that flares in conflict between partners, which he called common couple violence, and systematic violence used to dominate a partner, which he called patriarchal terrorism. In 2007 Evan Stark's book Coercive Control described the second pattern as one that need not involve physical violence at all: a campaign of intimidation, isolation and control that strips a person of their liberty. That idea now sits in Australian law. NSW made coercive control of a current or former intimate partner a criminal offence from 1 July 2024, and Queensland's offence, which also covers family members and unpaid carers, began on 26 May 2025.
Control can be hard to see from the inside, because it can arrive gradually and it can look like care. Wanting to know where you are, or worrying about a friend who is a bad influence, can sound loving. What matters is the pattern over time, and whether you feel free to say no. The guide to red flags looks at early signs in more detail.
How to tell if your relationship is toxic: questions to ask yourself
Ask yourself honest questions about how you feel, not only about what your partner does. These can help you sort one situation from the other:
- Am I ever afraid of my partner, or of what will happen if I disagree?
- Do I still see friends and family as much as I want to?
- Do I have access to my own money, phone and transport?
- After an argument, can we both apologise and move on?
- Do I feel more like myself in this relationship, or less?
- Would I be worried if a friend described this relationship to me?
If your honest answers point to fear or lost freedom, the problem is not your communication skills. If they point to hurt, distance and the same fight on repeat, the patterns are real but they may be changeable, and the guide to whether a relationship is healthy is a good next step.
Can a toxic relationship be fixed?
An unhealthy relationship can be, when both people see the pattern and want to change it; a controlling one is different, because the change has to come from the person using control. On the unhealthy side, the patterns are well described. In a 1992 study, John Gottman and Robert Levenson observed 73 married couples in 1983 and again in 1987, and the couples at greater risk of separating showed more negative emotion, more defensiveness, and more stubbornness and withdrawal. Those are habits, and habits can be practised differently, with honest conversations, repair after fights and, where it helps, a couples counsellor. The guide to signs a relationship is in trouble covers that ground. Where one partner is afraid of the other, couples counselling can be unsafe, because what you say in the room may be held against you afterwards, and a specialist family violence service is the better first call.
Where does the term toxic relationship come from?
The word toxic comes from a Greek word for the poison put on arrows. Self-help writers were already applying it to people by the 1990s, in books such as Lillian Glass's Toxic People in 1995. By 2018 it was so widespread that Oxford Dictionaries chose toxic as its word of the year, noting that people were applying it to workplaces, schools, cultures and relationships. Researchers have mostly used other language. Graham Spanier's 1976 Dyadic Adjustment Scale measured the quality of a relationship through satisfaction, cohesion, consensus and affection. Gottman's laboratory studies from the 1980s onwards described the specific conflict behaviours that wear a relationship down. Johnson in 1995 and Stark in 2007 gave the field its language for the controlling end of the spectrum, which is the end the popular word can hide.
How do you find out whether your own relationship is under strain?
Look at the whole relationship, not only the worst moments. Compatify's Comprehensive Relationship Health Audit is the most in-depth relationship assessment on the site. It looks at fifteen areas: emotional intimacy, trust and security, communication quality, conflict repair, shared meaning and values, physical and sexual connection, friendship and fondness, appreciation and gratitude, autonomy and interdependence, financial partnership, daily partnership and fairness, future vision and goals, support during stress, fun, novelty and romance, and commitment and loyalty. Your result gives one overall picture of how the relationship is doing from your side, which can help you decide what to work on, and you can compare your result with your partner's if it is safe to do so.
The framework behind this
Spanier's 1976 paper in the Journal of Marriage and the Family introduced the Dyadic Adjustment Scale and its four parts of relationship quality. Funk and Rogge's 2007 paper in the Journal of Family Psychology developed the Couples Satisfaction Index as a more precise measure of satisfaction. Gottman and Levenson's 1992 study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology linked defensiveness, withdrawal and negative emotion in conflict to later separation. Johnson's 1995 paper in the Journal of Marriage and the Family separated conflict-driven violence from violence used to dominate, and Stark's 2007 book from Oxford University Press defined coercive control. Compatify's test is grounded in the Dyadic Adjustment Scale, the Couples Satisfaction Index and Gottman's relationship research. It is science-informed self-reflection, not a clinical evaluation.
What this cannot tell you
A result describes your relationship as you experience it. It cannot tell you whether you are being abused, it is not a safety assessment, and a good score does not cancel out fear in your home. It cannot label your partner, and neither can a list of signs. If anything in this guide made you think of fear, control or violence, safety comes first. If your partner checks your phone or devices, think about whether it is safe to search or take a test on them. In Australia, 1800RESPECT is on 1800 737 732, at any hour, for anyone affected by family, domestic or sexual violence. Lifeline is on 13 11 14. MensLine Australia, on 1300 78 99 78, supports men, including men worried about their own behaviour. Anyone in immediate danger should call 000.
Common questions
- What are the signs of a toxic relationship?
- Unhealthy signs include constant criticism, contempt, arguments that never resolve, shutting down and feeling lonely together. Signs of control include fear of your partner, being cut off from friends or money, having your phone checked and threats. The second group needs a safety response first.
- What is the difference between a toxic and an abusive relationship?
- Toxic is a loose everyday word. An abusive or controlling relationship is a specific pattern where one person uses fear, intimidation, isolation or threats to dominate the other. An unhealthy relationship can be painful without anyone being afraid or losing their freedom.
- Is coercive control a crime in Australia?
- In some states, yes. NSW made coercive control of a current or former intimate partner a criminal offence from 1 July 2024, Queensland's offence began on 26 May 2025, and Tasmania has had offences for emotional and economic abuse since 2005. 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732 can talk through options anywhere in Australia.
- Can a toxic relationship become healthy again?
- An unhealthy relationship can change when both people recognise the pattern and practise different habits, sometimes with a counsellor's help. A controlling relationship is different, because the change has to come from the person using control, and safety comes before working on the relationship.
- Why is it so hard to leave a toxic relationship?
- Leaving can be hard for many reasons: love, shared children or money, hope that things will improve, and doubt about your own judgement. 1800RESPECT notes that women who leave a violent partner may face more severe violence, so planning with a specialist service is a sensible step.
Sources
- Spanier, G. B. (1976). Measuring dyadic adjustment: new scales for assessing the quality of marriage and similar dyads. Journal of Marriage and the Family.
- Gottman, J. M. and Levenson, R. W. (1992). Marital processes predictive of later dissolution: behavior, physiology, and health. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
- Johnson, M. P. (1995). Patriarchal terrorism and common couple violence: two forms of violence against women. Journal of Marriage and the Family.
- Funk, J. L. and Rogge, R. D. (2007). Testing the ruler with item response theory: increasing precision of measurement for relationship satisfaction with the Couples Satisfaction Index. Journal of Family Psychology.
- Stark, E. (2007). Coercive Control: How Men Entrap Women in Personal Life. Oxford University Press.