Staying Together for the Kids: What the Research Says
Family · · Updated · 10 min read
Short answer
Staying together for the kids is linked to better outcomes for children when the marriage is low in conflict, and to worse outcomes when conflict is high. In American studies by Paul Amato and Alan Booth, children from high-conflict marriages fared better as adults after a divorce. What matters most is the conflict children live with, not the decision itself.
By the Compatify Editorial Team · Sources checked . Science-informed self-reflection, not clinical advice. How we write and check guides.
It is after ten and the house is finally quiet. You are sitting in the car in the driveway because it is the only place nobody will ask what is wrong. Inside, the school notices are on the bench, the lunchboxes need washing, and the person you married is watching television in a room you no longer walk into. You have run the numbers on rent. You have pictured telling the kids. And every time, the same sentence stops you: they need us both under one roof.
That sentence deserves a better answer than guilt. Researchers have spent decades asking whether children do better when unhappy parents stay together, and their answer is more useful than yes or no. It turns, to a large degree, on how much conflict your children live with, whichever house they end up in.
What does staying together for the kids mean?
Staying together for the kids means remaining in a relationship you would otherwise leave, mainly because you believe separating would harm your children. The marriage may be calm but empty, or loud and full of arguments the children can hear. From the outside both look like a family that did not split, but the research treats them very differently.
Is it better to stay together for the kids?
It can be, when the marriage is low in conflict, and it tends not to be when conflict is high. Paul Amato, Laura Spencer Loomis and Alan Booth followed American families for 12 years and reported in 1995 that the effect of divorce depended on the conflict before it. In high-conflict families, children had higher well-being as young adults if their parents divorced than if they stayed together. In low-conflict families the pattern reversed: children did better if their parents stayed. Among parents who never divorced, more marital conflict went with lower well-being in their grown children.
Booth and Amato returned to the question in 2001 with national longitudinal interviews of parents and their adult children. The ending of low-conflict marriages appeared to have negative effects on offspring, including on the quality of their own intimate relationships and their social support, while the ending of high-conflict marriages appeared to have beneficial effects. Both studies are American, and both describe averages, not a forecast for your family.
| Situation | What the studies suggest for children | What to focus on |
|---|---|---|
| Low conflict, parents stay | Higher average well-being in adulthood than if parents divorced | Staying well: warmth, teamwork and repair, not just staying |
| Low conflict, parents divorce | Appeared to carry negative effects into adult relationships | Whether the marriage can be renewed before it is ended |
| High conflict, parents stay | Lower average well-being in adulthood | Reducing the conflict children see and hear, or separating well |
| High conflict, parents divorce | Higher average well-being than if parents stayed | Keeping conflict away from children after the separation |
| Violence, threats or fear at home | Outcomes not significantly different from physical abuse | Safety first, with a plan made with specialist support |
Staying together for the kids: pros and cons
The honest list cuts both ways, because divorce on its own is not neutral for children. Amato's 2001 meta-analysis of 67 studies published in the 1990s found that children with divorced parents still scored lower on average than children with continuously married parents on academic achievement, conduct, psychological adjustment, self-concept and social relations. That gap is an average, and it includes families whose children may have been helped.
- Possible pro: children keep one home, one routine and daily contact with both parents.
- Possible pro: you avoid the cost of running two households.
- Possible pro: if the marriage is low in conflict, it may recover, and the research suggests children benefit if it does.
- Possible con: children may pick up tension even when nobody shouts.
- Possible con: in Amato's studies, high parental conflict went with lower well-being in grown children, including in marriages that never ended.
- Possible con: staying for years out of duty can wear down your own health, which children also live with.
Should I stay in a relationship for my kids?
Only you can answer that, but the research suggests better questions than whether staying is noble. These are worth answering honestly, on paper, before you decide anything:
- How often do the children see or hear us argue, and how do those arguments end?
- Is the problem conflict, or distance? A cold marriage and a hostile one are different situations.
- Have we both tried to fix it, with a counsellor, or has only one of us tried?
- Do I feel safe at home, and do the children?
- If we stayed, what would staying well look like, and could we both commit to it?
- If we separated, could we keep the children out of the middle?
- Am I staying for the children, or because leaving frightens me for other reasons?
If you are still unsure whether the relationship itself has ended, the guide to knowing when a relationship is over looks at that question on its own terms.
What is the difference between staying and staying well?
Staying is a living arrangement; staying well is a working partnership in raising your children. Mark Feinberg's 2003 framework describes co-parenting as its own relationship, separate from the romance, built from four parts: how far you agree on raising your child, whether you support or undermine each other as parents, how you divide the work, and how you manage family moments together. A couple can be distant as partners and still strong on all four. When parents disagree about rules, bedtimes or discipline, the guide to parenting disagreements covers how to settle them without turning them into a contest.
How do you co-parent through a separation?
You co-parent through a separation by treating the parenting partnership as something that continues after the romance ends. The aim is the same as in an intact family: keep conflict away from the children.
- Tell the children together if you safely can, in plain words, and tell them it is not their fault.
- Never use a child as a messenger, a spy or a sounding board for complaints about the other parent.
- Keep handovers short and calm; save disagreements for when the children are elsewhere.
- Keep routines, rules and school contact as consistent across both homes as you can.
- Put the parenting arrangements in writing, and review them as the children grow.
- Use family dispute resolution if you cannot agree. In Australia, the Family Relationship Advice Line on 1800 050 321 can explain options and refer you to services.
The co-parenting guide goes further into what good co-parenting looks like, together or apart, including parallel parenting when contact itself causes conflict.
What if there is violence or fear in the home?
Then the question changes, and safety comes first. Kitzmann and colleagues' 2003 meta-analysis of 118 studies found that children who witnessed violence between their parents had significantly worse outcomes than children who did not, and their outcomes were not significantly different from those of children who were physically abused themselves. Australian family law reflects this: under section 4AB of the Family Law Act 1975, a child is exposed to family violence if they see or hear it or otherwise experience its effects. Under family law, violence, threats and fear count the first time they happen, and so can controlling behaviour; a repeated pattern of coercive control against a current or former intimate partner has also been a criminal offence in New South Wales since 1 July 2024, and in Queensland, where the offence also covers family members and unpaid carers, since 26 May 2025. Staying for the kids is not a reason to stay in danger, and leaving is best planned with specialist support rather than alone. 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732 can help you make a safety plan at any hour, and anyone in immediate danger should call 000.
Where does the idea of staying together for the kids come from?
For much of the twentieth century, staying was less a choice than a rule. Before Australia's Family Law Act 1975 took effect on 5 January 1976, divorce law was largely based on fault: of the 14 grounds under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1959, most were matrimonial offences such as adultery or desertion, and the only no-fault route required five years' separation. The Act replaced fault with a single ground, the irretrievable breakdown of the marriage, shown by at least 12 months' separation. As divorce became easier, researchers began asking whether children were paying the price. Paul Amato and Alan Booth's 1997 book A Generation at Risk, published by Harvard University Press, drew on a study of American families begun in 1980 and followed into the children's adulthood. Its central point, also made in their journal papers, was that the conflict before a divorce shapes what the divorce means for the children.
How do you find out how well you co-parent together?
Compatify's Co-Parenting Compatibility Test is built on Feinberg's co-parenting framework. It is designed to help you reflect on how well your co-parenting values, approaches and goals line up, how consistently you communicate about your child, and how far you share a commitment to your child's wellbeing, whether you are together, separating or already apart. Take it, ask the other parent to take it, and compare your result with theirs.
The framework behind this
Amato, Loomis and Booth's 1995 paper in Social Forces showed that the effect of divorce on children depended on the conflict that came before it. Booth and Amato's 2001 paper in the Journal of Marriage and Family repeated that contrast. Amato's 2001 meta-analysis in the Journal of Family Psychology set out what divorce is linked to on average. Kitzmann and colleagues' 2003 meta-analysis in the Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology established what witnessing violence is linked to. Feinberg's 2003 framework in Parenting: Science and Practice supplies the four parts of co-parenting. Compatify's test is grounded in Feinberg's co-parenting framework. It is science-informed self-reflection, not a clinical evaluation.
What this cannot tell you
A result describes how you see your co-parenting. It cannot tell you whether to stay or leave, predict how your children will cope, or replace legal advice about parenting arrangements, property or divorce; a family lawyer, a community legal centre or the Family Relationship Advice Line on 1800 050 321 can help with those. If there is violence, threats, control or fear in your home, safety comes before any test: call 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732, or 000 in an emergency. Children and young people aged 5 to 25 can call Kids Helpline on 1800 55 1800 themselves.
Common questions
- Is it better to stay together for the kids?
- It depends on conflict. American research by Amato and Booth suggests children of low-conflict marriages do better if their parents stay together, while children of high-conflict marriages tend to do better as adults if their parents separate.
- What does the research say about staying together for the kids?
- American studies following families over many years link high parental conflict to lower well-being for children, whether or not the parents divorce. Divorce is linked to lower average outcomes, but those averages include families where it helped.
- Is a low-conflict but unhappy marriage worth staying in for the children?
- The research suggests children of low-conflict marriages tend to fare better if their parents stay, so it is worth trying to renew the relationship first, perhaps with a couples counsellor.
- Does arguing in front of children harm them?
- Ordinary disagreements that end in a resolution are part of family life. Ongoing high conflict is what Amato and Booth's research links to lower well-being, and violence that children see or hear counts as family violence under Australian family law.
- How do I tell my kids we are separating?
- Together if it is safe, in plain and age-appropriate words, without blaming the other parent. Tell them it is not their fault, explain what will stay the same, and let them ask questions over the following weeks.
Sources
- Amato, P. R., Loomis, L. S. and Booth, A. (1995). Parental divorce, marital conflict, and offspring well-being during early adulthood. Social Forces.
- Booth, A. and Amato, P. R. (2001). Parental predivorce relations and offspring postdivorce well-being. Journal of Marriage and Family.
- Amato, P. R. (2001). Children of divorce in the 1990s: an update of the Amato and Keith (1991) meta-analysis. Journal of Family Psychology.
- Kitzmann, K. M., Gaylord, N. K., Holt, A. R. and Kenny, E. D. (2003). Child witnesses to domestic violence: a meta-analytic review. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology.
- Feinberg, M. E. (2003). The internal structure and ecological context of coparenting: a framework for research and intervention. Parenting: Science and Practice.