Relationship Anxiety: How to Stop Overthinking Your Relationship
Psychology · · 10 min read
Short answer
Relationship anxiety is persistent doubt about a relationship, such as whether your partner loves you, whether they will leave, or whether it is right, that feels bigger than the evidence. It is linked to attachment anxiety. Reassurance calms it briefly before the doubt returns; learning to sit with some uncertainty, alone or with a psychologist, can help.
By the Compatify Editorial Team · Sources checked . Science-informed self-reflection, not clinical advice. How we write and check guides.
Your partner said they would call after work. It is now quarter to eight. You have checked whether they were online, reread the last three messages for a change in tone, and drafted a text that sounds casual and deleted it twice. When the call comes, they are cheerful and apologetic and the relief is enormous. By Thursday the same feeling is back, attached to something new: a short reply, a night out without you, a look you could not read.
Nothing is necessarily wrong in that relationship. That is what makes relationship anxiety so tiring: the worry does not need evidence, and when evidence arrives that everything is fine, the relief does not last. The loop has a recognisable shape, though, and once you can see it, you can start to step out of it.
What is relationship anxiety?
Relationship anxiety is a pattern of persistent worry and doubt about a romantic relationship that feels out of proportion to what is actually happening: whether your partner really loves you, whether they are about to leave, or whether this is the right relationship at all. It can come with behaviour as well as thought, such as checking, rereading, seeking reassurance and testing your own feelings. It is not a clinical label but a description of a pattern, and it can show up in a new relationship or a long marriage.
Why do I feel insecure in my relationship?
You may feel insecure in a relationship because your attachment system, the part of you that monitors whether the people you depend on are close and available, is set to a high level of alert. Attachment theory, developed by John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth to explain the bonds between infants and carers, proposes that early experience shapes working models of whether you are worth loving and whether others will stay. In 1987 Cindy Hazan and Phillip Shaver extended the theory to adult romance. In two American questionnaire studies, adults who described themselves as anxious or ambivalent experienced love differently from those who described themselves as secure, and their attachment style related to how they saw themselves and to their memories of their parents. Someone who leans towards what researchers now call attachment anxiety may read silence as rejection and a delay as a warning. The attachment styles guide explains the wider picture, and insecurity can also have a present-day cause: a partner who is genuinely inconsistent, or a past betrayal.
| Pattern | What the worry centres on | What it can sound like |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship anxiety | Whether you are loved, whether they will stay, whether it is safe | They have gone quiet, have I done something? |
| Jealousy | A third person, real or imagined, who could take your place | Who is she, and why did he laugh like that? |
| General overthinking | Many areas of life, with the relationship as one of them | What if work goes wrong, what if the money runs out? |
| Relationship-centred obsessive doubts, as Doron describes them | Whether you really love your partner, whether they love you, whether the relationship is right | I need to know for certain that this is the one |
| Partner-focused obsessive doubts, as Doron describes them | A partner's perceived flaws in looks, intelligence, sociability or morals | I keep noticing their flaws, and it must mean something |
If the worry is mainly about another person, the jealousy guide is the better fit. If it spreads across your whole life, the overthinking guide covers worry in general.
Why does reassurance help for a moment and then stop working?
One explanation, drawn from research on reassurance-seeking and on obsessive doubts, is that reassurance answers the doubt without changing the habit of doubting. In 1999 Thomas Joiner, Gerald Metalsky, Jennifer Katz and Steven Beach summarised a research programme on excessive reassurance-seeking and depression, arguing that it can contribute to low mood and to strain in relationships. In 2005 Phillip Shaver, Dory Schachner and Mario Mikulincer studied young unmarried couples, 72 in one study and 61 in a second that added a daily diary over 14 days. Excessive reassurance-seeking was related to depression only because of its link to attachment anxiety, and partners did notice each other's reassurance-seeking. The pattern can run like this: a doubt appears, you ask, you get a yes, you feel relief, and then you start to wonder whether the yes was meant. Doron and colleagues describe reassurance seeking as a compulsive behaviour aimed at easing distress, which helps explain why the relief does not last.
How do you stop overthinking in a relationship?
You stop overthinking in a relationship by changing what you do when the doubt arrives, not by finding the one answer that finally silences it. None of these asks you to pretend you are not worried:
- Name it when it happens: this is the anxious loop, not new information about my relationship.
- Delay the check. When you want to reread messages or look at when they were last online, wait and see whether the urge passes on its own.
- Ask for reassurance once, clearly, and then let the answer stand instead of asking again in a different way.
- Tell your partner about the pattern at a calm moment, so a request for reassurance is understood rather than taken as an accusation.
- Notice what usually sets it off, such as tiredness, a long gap in contact or an evening alone, and plan for those times.
- Keep your own life full, so your attention has somewhere to go other than the relationship.
- If the anxiety feels driven by something your partner is doing, raise that behaviour directly rather than managing your feelings around it.
How do you stop overthinking in a new relationship?
In a new relationship, overthinking can feed on real uncertainty, so the most useful step is to reduce the uncertainty you can and accept the rest. Early on an anxious mind can treat every unanswered question as a threat. Say what you want, ask what they want, and let the pace be steady rather than rushed. Speeding things up to make the anxiety go away can make it worse, a pattern the guide to moving too fast looks at. If you notice the same fear in every new relationship, regardless of the person, that is a sign the pattern is yours to work on, and the guide to changing your attachment style is a good next step.
What is relationship OCD, and what causes it?
Relationship OCD is a term researchers use for obsessive doubts and compulsive checking that centre on a romantic relationship or partner; it is not listed as a separate condition in the DSM-5, and only a qualified mental health professional can say whether OCD applies to you. In 2014 Guy Doron, Danny Derby and Ohad Szepsenwol set out a conceptual framework for what they called relationship obsessive compulsive disorder. In a 2016 study in Israel, Doron and colleagues compared 22 clients with these symptoms, 22 clients with other OCD presentations and 28 community participants. They described two kinds of symptom: relationship-centred doubts about your feelings, your partner's feelings and whether the relationship is right, and partner-focused preoccupation with a partner's perceived flaws. They list repeated monitoring of your own feelings and reassurance seeking among the compulsive behaviours. Why it develops in one person and not another is still being studied. If the doubts take up hours of your day or feel impossible to resist, a GP or psychologist can help.
When is relationship anxiety telling you something real?
Relationship anxiety is telling you something real when the worry tracks a pattern you can see, not just a feeling you cannot shake. A partner who regularly breaks promises, hides things or mocks your concerns is giving you information, and anxiety in response is not a flaw in you. If your partner checks your phone, controls who you see, threatens you, or makes you afraid of how they will react, that is not an anxiety pattern to manage, and safety comes first. The red flags guide covers the warning signs, and 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732 is there at any hour.
Where does the idea of relationship anxiety come from?
The idea comes mainly from attachment theory. Bowlby's mid-twentieth-century work proposed that people carry expectations about closeness and loss from early relationships, and Hazan and Shaver's 1987 paper brought that idea into adult romantic love. Joiner and colleagues' research programme on excessive reassurance-seeking, summarised in 1999, added the reassurance loop, and Shaver, Schachner and Mikulincer tied that loop to attachment anxiety in 2005. Doron's group began publishing on relationship-centred and partner-focused obsessive-compulsive symptoms in 2012 and set out a full framework in 2014. Relationship anxiety itself is an everyday phrase rather than a formal term.
How do you find your own reassurance pattern?
Because relationship anxiety is linked to attachment anxiety, Compatify's Attachment Style Test is the most direct way to look at your own pattern. It is grounded in the Experiences in Close Relationships-Revised scale, scores you on two dimensions, anxiety and avoidance, and then names the style those scores point to. It is meant to show patterns you can work with, not to label you, and if your partner takes it too, a Premium comparison report shows where your patterns differ so you can talk about them together.
The framework behind this
Hazan and Shaver's 1987 paper in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology supplies the link between attachment and adult romantic love. Joiner, Metalsky, Katz and Beach's 1999 article in Psychological Inquiry supplies excessive reassurance-seeking, and Shaver, Schachner and Mikulincer's 2005 paper in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin ties it to attachment anxiety in couples. Doron and colleagues' 2014 framework and 2016 study describe relationship-focused obsessive doubts. The Attachment Style Test is grounded in the Experiences in Close Relationships-Revised scale of adult attachment. It is science-informed self-reflection, not a clinical evaluation.
What this cannot tell you
A result describes your patterns of doubt and reassurance as you report them. It cannot tell you whether your partner loves you, whether your relationship is right for you, or whether a clinical condition such as OCD or an anxiety condition is involved; only a qualified professional can assess that. It also cannot tell the difference between anxiety and a reasonable response to a partner who is unreliable or unsafe. If anxiety is affecting your sleep, work or mood, Beyond Blue is on 1300 22 4636, and if you are in crisis, Lifeline is on 13 11 14. If you feel afraid of your partner, 1800RESPECT is on 1800 737 732, and anyone in immediate danger should call 000.
Common questions
- Is it normal to have anxiety in a relationship?
- Some worry is an ordinary part of caring about someone, especially early on or after a hurt. It becomes a pattern worth working on when it is constant, outweighs the evidence, and keeps returning however much reassurance you get.
- How do I stop overthinking in my relationship?
- Change what you do when the doubt arrives: name the loop, delay the urge to check, ask for reassurance once and let the answer stand, and keep your own life full. Talking to your partner about the pattern at a calm moment also helps.
- What causes relationship OCD thoughts?
- Guy Doron's research group points to possible roles for beliefs about relationships, personality, parenting and family environment, but there is no single known cause. Only a qualified professional can say whether the term fits you, and a GP or psychologist can help.
- Does reassurance help relationship anxiety?
- It helps for a moment. Research on excessive reassurance-seeking, from Joiner and colleagues and later Shaver and colleagues, ties repeated asking to attachment anxiety and low mood. Asking once and letting the answer stand is one way to start stepping out of the cycle.
- Can relationship anxiety go away?
- It can ease. Recognising the loop, changing how you respond to doubt and building security inside and outside the relationship can all make it quieter, and a psychologist can help if it stays loud or keeps returning.
Sources
- Hazan, C. and Shaver, P. (1987). Romantic love conceptualized as an attachment process. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
- Joiner, T. E., Metalsky, G. I., Katz, J. and Beach, S. R. H. (1999). Depression and excessive reassurance-seeking. Psychological Inquiry.
- Shaver, P. R., Schachner, D. A. and Mikulincer, M. (2005). Attachment style, excessive reassurance seeking, relationship processes, and depression. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin.
- Doron, G., Derby, D. S. and Szepsenwol, O. (2014). Relationship obsessive compulsive disorder (ROCD): a conceptual framework. Journal of Obsessive-Compulsive and Related Disorders.
- Doron, G., Derby, D., Szepsenwol, O., Nahaloni, E. and Moulding, R. (2016). Relationship obsessive-compulsive disorder: interference, symptoms, and maladaptive beliefs. Frontiers in Psychiatry.