In-Law Problems: How to Handle Difficult In-Laws as a Team
Family · · 9 min read
Short answer
In-law problems become couple problems when the two of you disagree about loyalty and limits. The fix is to agree your boundaries privately first, have each partner handle their own family, and present decisions as joint. A united couple gives in-laws one clear message to adjust to.
By the Compatify Editorial Team · Sources checked . Science-informed self-reflection, not clinical advice. How we write and check guides.
The car is quiet on the drive home from Sunday lunch. Your partner's mother asked, again, when you were planning to have children, and then told a story about how she did things when your partner was a baby, looking at you the whole time. Your partner laughed along. Now you are staring out the window rehearsing two speeches: one about your mother-in-law, and one about the person sitting next to you who said nothing.
That second speech is usually the one that matters. In-law tension rarely stays between the in-law and the newcomer. It becomes a question about the couple. Whose side are you on? Whose family gets Christmas? Who decides what gets said to whom? Answering those as a team makes difficult in-laws easier to manage. Answer them separately and even a well-meaning family can drive a wedge between you.
What are in-law problems?
In-law problems are recurring tensions between a couple and one or both partners' families, usually over boundaries, loyalty, advice, privacy, money, holidays, religion or how children are raised. They range from mild, such as a parent who drops in unannounced, to serious, such as a family that undermines the relationship or tries to control decisions. What makes them distinctive is the triangle. A friend who oversteps is your problem to manage. A parent who oversteps belongs to your partner, and how your partner responds becomes part of the problem or part of the solution.
Why do in-laws cause so much tension?
In-laws cause tension because a new couple is quietly renegotiating who belongs to whom, and nobody says so out loud. The parent who spent decades at the centre of their child's life now shares that place. The new partner arrives with their own family's rules for everything from birthdays to how often you call. Terri Apter, a psychologist who interviewed in-laws in Britain and the United States for her 2009 book What Do You Want from Me?, argues that much of the friction comes from vulnerability on both sides: a fear of losing an important place in the family, which comes out as criticism, competition or coldness.
Family therapists have described the same dynamic for decades. Murray Bowen observed that when two people in a family are anxious with each other, they tend to pull in a third person to steady things, a pattern he called triangulation. A mother who confides her worries about your relationship to your partner, rather than raising them with you, is triangling. So is a partner who complains about their own parent to you instead of talking to the parent. Triangles relieve pressure in the moment and keep the real conversation from happening.
How do you deal with difficult in-laws?
You deal with difficult in-laws by settling things between the two of you first and letting each partner lead with their own family. In-law conflict is much harder to handle when the couple arrives at the conversation divided.
- Agree your boundaries privately before the visit, the phone call or the holiday, including what you will say if a particular topic comes up.
- Let each partner handle their own family. Your mother hears a hard no better from her own child than from the person she sees as the reason for it.
- Present decisions as joint. We have decided lands very differently from my partner does not want.
- Never ask your partner to choose between you and their parent. Ask them to stand with you on a specific decision.
- Keep criticism of your partner's family brief and specific. Your father interrupts me can be worked on. Your family is toxic cannot.
- Give the family something to say yes to. A firm limit on drop-in visits is easier to accept alongside a standing invitation to Sunday dinner.
- Review what is working after big family events, while it is fresh, rather than letting resentment build until the next one.
What if my partner will not stand up to their parents?
If your partner will not stand up to their parents, start by finding out what standing up would cost them, because it is rarely as simple as not caring about you. Some people grew up in families where disagreeing with a parent meant weeks of silence. Others feel a real duty of care, especially to an ageing or unwell parent. Ask what they are afraid will happen, and ask for one specific thing rather than a change of character: will you tell your mum we are spending Christmas morning at home this year?
The research suggests this is worth getting right. Terri Orbuch and colleagues followed couples for 16 years from the first year of their marriage and found that how close spouses felt to their in-laws early on was linked to their odds of divorce over the following years, with the pattern differing by gender and race. In-law relationships are not a side issue. If talking about this always ends with one of you shouting and the other shutting down, the conflict-styles guide explains why, and what to do in the moment.
| Problem | What it often means | A first step |
|---|---|---|
| Unsolicited advice, especially about children | A wish to stay useful and involved | Thank them, decline the advice, and invite them into something else |
| Dropping in unannounced | Different family rules about privacy | The related partner agrees a simple rule with them, such as texting first |
| Holiday tug of war | Both families feel their tradition is the normal one | Agree a rotation or a split as a couple, then announce it together |
| Criticism of the newcomer | Fear of losing a place in their child's life | The related partner addresses it directly and early |
| Partner confides in a parent about fights | A triangle that relieves pressure and blocks repair | Agree what stays between the two of you |
| Money with strings attached | Help that buys influence over decisions | Decide together whether the help is worth the strings |
How do you set boundaries with in-laws without starting a war?
You set boundaries with in-laws by stating what you will do, not what they must do, and by saying it calmly, early and more than once. A boundary is a decision about your own behaviour: we will leave by eight, we will not discuss our finances, we will text back when we can. It does not require the other person to agree. It does require you to follow through. A limit that is announced and then quietly dropped teaches a family that limits are negotiable. The guide to healthy family boundaries goes further into the difference between a boundary and an ultimatum.
Where does the idea of in-law boundaries come from?
The language most people now use for in-law tension comes from two founders of family therapy. Murray Bowen, an American psychiatrist, developed family systems theory from the 1950s onward and collected his papers in Family Therapy in Clinical Practice in 1978. He gave us triangulation and differentiation of self, the capacity to stay yourself while remaining connected to your family. Salvador Minuchin set out structural family therapy in Families and Family Therapy in 1974. He described families as systems with boundaries between their parts, and he argued that boundaries can be too loose, so that members are enmeshed in each other's business, or too rigid, so that they are disengaged and cut off. A new couple, in Minuchin's terms, has to build a clear boundary around itself while staying connected to both families. Self-help writing about in-laws, including Apter's, draws heavily on this tradition.
How do you find out where your relationship stands?
It helps to know which part of the in-law triangle is under strain before you try to fix it. Compatify's In-Laws & Extended Family Stress Test looks at how your relationship functions when in-laws or extended family become a source of pressure: emotional spillover, boundary clarity, partner alignment, communication, flexibility and your ability to stay connected without becoming overrun. Take it with your partner and compare. Look closely at any gap between how aligned each of you thinks you are. If the strain is about how to raise children, the parenting disagreements guide is the next step.
The framework behind this
Salvador Minuchin's Families and Family Therapy supplies the idea of family boundaries that are clear, enmeshed or disengaged. Murray Bowen's Family Therapy in Clinical Practice supplies triangulation and differentiation of self. Terri Apter's What Do You Want from Me? supplies the account of in-law tension as a struggle over place and belonging. Orbuch, Bauermeister, Brown and McKinley's 2013 study in Family Relations supplies the link between early in-law ties and marital stability. Compatify's test is its own reflection tool, informed by family systems theory and boundary-setting concepts, and it is not an adaptation of any published scale. It is science-informed self-reflection, not a clinical evaluation.
What this cannot tell you
A result describes how family pressure feels inside your relationship. It cannot tell you what your in-laws intend, whether a particular relative will change, or whether stepping back from a family is the right call. Those depend on history the test cannot see. Some family situations are not about boundaries at all. If a relative threatens you, controls money or contact, or makes you afraid, safety comes first. In Australia, 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732 supports anyone affected by family, domestic or sexual violence, and Lifeline is available on 13 11 14 if the strain is becoming too much.
Common questions
- How do I deal with a mother-in-law who criticises me?
- Ask your partner to raise it with their mother directly and early, using a specific example. Meanwhile, keep your own responses brief and calm. A united couple leaves a critical parent less room to push.
- Should my partner defend me to their parents?
- Your partner should support the decisions you make together, and address clear disrespect, with their own family. That is different from taking sides in every disagreement, which tends to harden positions on both sides.
- How do we split holidays between two families fairly?
- Decide as a couple before either family asks. Common options are alternating years, splitting the day, or hosting both families. Announce the plan together and keep to it, rather than renegotiating each year under pressure.
- Is it normal to not get along with your in-laws?
- Yes. Friction with in-laws is not unusual, especially around children and holidays. It becomes a problem for the couple mainly when the two partners disagree about how to handle it.
- When is it okay to limit contact with in-laws?
- When contact consistently harms your relationship or wellbeing despite clear, repeated boundaries. It is a decision for the two of you to make together, ideally with support from a counsellor, rather than in the heat of one visit.
Sources
- Minuchin, S. (1974). Families and Family Therapy. Harvard University Press.
- Bowen, M. (1978). Family Therapy in Clinical Practice. Jason Aronson.
- Apter, T. (2009). What Do You Want from Me? Learning to Get Along with In-Laws. W. W. Norton.
- Orbuch, T. L., Bauermeister, J. A., Brown, E. and McKinley, B.-D. (2013). Early family ties and marital stability over 16 years: the context of race and gender. Family Relations.