Humor Styles in Relationships: Which Help and Which Hurt
Lifestyle · · 8 min read
Short answer
Psychologist Rod Martin and colleagues identified four humour styles: affiliative, self-enhancing, aggressive and self-defeating. In relationships, the first two help and the last two tend to hurt. A meta-analysis found positive humour linked to higher satisfaction, and shared humour mattered far more than how funny each person rated themselves.
By the Compatify Editorial Team · Sources checked . Science-informed self-reflection, not clinical advice. How we write and check guides.
You are at a friend's dinner party and your partner tells the story about the time you got lost driving to your own wedding. Everyone laughs. You laugh too, a beat late. It is a good story, and it is true, but it is the fourth time this year, and you are starting to wonder whether the joke is about the two of you or about you.
Many people say they want a partner with a good sense of humour. But humour is not one thing. The same quick wit that makes a partner fun at a party can make them hard to have a serious conversation with, and the gentle teasing that feels affectionate to one person can land as a jab to the other. What matters in a relationship is less whether you are funny and more how you use it.
What are humor styles?
Humour styles are the characteristic ways a person uses humour in everyday life: to connect with others, to cope with stress, to put others down, or to put themselves down to win approval. The psychologist Rod Martin and his colleagues described four styles in 2003 when they developed the Humor Styles Questionnaire. Two are benign and two are potentially harmful, and each person uses a mix. The idea shifted the question from how much humour someone has to what their humour is doing.
| Style | What it sounds like | What it does in a relationship |
|---|---|---|
| Affiliative | Shared jokes, playful banter, laughing together at the absurd | Builds closeness and eases tension without anyone paying for it |
| Self-enhancing | Finding the funny side of a bad day, a light outlook under stress | Helps you cope, and keeps a hard week from becoming a hard relationship |
| Aggressive | Sarcasm, ridicule, teasing that targets a sore spot | Can slide into put-downs and contempt, especially in front of others |
| Self-defeating | Making yourself the punchline to be liked, joking to hide hurt | Can mask real feelings, so a partner never hears what is wrong |
Which humour styles help a relationship?
Affiliative and self-enhancing humour help. Affiliative humour is the shared laughter that makes two people feel like a team: the private joke, the look across a crowded room, the ability to laugh about the burnt dinner rather than fight about it. Self-enhancing humour is the capacity to keep a good-natured perspective when things go wrong, which matters because relationships spend a lot of time in things going wrong. Neither style costs anyone anything. In Martin's original research, these two styles were associated with better psychological well-being, while the other two were associated with poorer well-being.
Which humour styles hurt a relationship?
Aggressive and self-defeating humour tend to hurt. Aggressive humour is joking at someone else's expense, and in a relationship that someone is usually the partner. A little teasing between people who trust each other can be affectionate. A steady diet of it, particularly about a partner's appearance, competence or family, starts to look less like play and more like contempt delivered with a laugh track. Self-defeating humour is quieter. The partner who always makes themselves the punchline may be easy company, but they can also be using the joke to avoid saying what they actually feel, which leaves the other person guessing.
Signs a joke has stopped being play:
- The same partner is always the target, and the joke is never reversed.
- It comes up most in front of friends or family.
- It touches a topic the other person has said hurts.
- When they object, the answer is you cannot take a joke.
- Humour arrives every time a serious conversation starts, so the conversation never happens.
If a pattern of put-downs sounds familiar, it often belongs to a bigger conflict dynamic, which the conflict-styles guide explores.
Does a shared sense of humour matter in a relationship?
Yes, and more than individual funniness does. Hall's 2017 meta-analysis in Personal Relationships combined 43 samples with more than 15,000 participants. All six positive types of humour he examined were associated with higher relationship satisfaction, and four of the five negative types with lower satisfaction. The most striking result was about perspective. How funny people said they were themselves showed only small links with satisfaction. How funny their partner found them showed a medium link, and humour that was shared between the two of them showed a large one. In plain terms, the couples who did best were not the ones with the funniest individual. They were the ones who laughed together.
Observational research on couples fits that picture. Janice Driver and John Gottman watched newlywed couples over an everyday dinnertime and then in a conflict discussion. Couples who were more playful and enthusiastic in ordinary moments used more humour and affection when they disagreed. The study was correlational, so it cannot show which came first, but it suggests the laughter you share on a quiet night may be the same laughter that softens a hard one.
| Matters more | Matters less |
|---|---|
| Humour you share and build together | How funny you rate yourself |
| Whether your partner enjoys your humour | Whether strangers at a party do |
| Playfulness in ordinary moments | Being the funniest person in the room |
| Humour that brings you closer | Humour that wins the point |
Where do humour styles come from?
People have theorised about laughter since antiquity, and everyday talk still treats a sense of humour as something you simply have more or less of. The idea of humour styles is much more recent. It came from Rod Martin and his colleagues Puhlik-Doris, Larsen, Gray and Weir, who published the Humor Styles Questionnaire in the Journal of Research in Personality in 2003. Their argument was that the same amount of humour can be used in healthy or unhealthy ways, and that the use is what predicts well-being. They organised humour along two lines: whether it is directed at enhancing yourself or your relationships with others, and whether it is benign or potentially harmful. Those two lines produce the four styles. The questionnaire has since been widely used and translated, though researchers have noted that the reliability of some scales, particularly the aggressive scale in translated versions, varies.
How do you find out how your humour lines up with your partner's?
Compatify's Humor Compatibility Test looks at the part of humour that matters most between two people. It scores your affiliative humour, the shared laughter that builds connection, and your self-enhancing humour, the way you keep perspective under stress, and it looks for humour mismatch, the places where what makes one of you laugh misses or stings the other. Take it, ask your partner to take it, and compare. A mismatch is not a verdict. It is a map of the jokes worth talking about. If you want the broader picture of what makes two people fit, the compatibility guide is the next step.
The framework behind this
Martin, Puhlik-Doris, Larsen, Gray and Weir's 2003 paper in the Journal of Research in Personality introduced the four humour styles and the Humor Styles Questionnaire, and linked the benign styles to better well-being. Hall's 2017 meta-analysis in Personal Relationships showed that positive humour is associated with relationship satisfaction and that shared humour matters more than self-rated humour. Driver and Gottman's 2004 study in Family Process linked everyday playfulness to humour and affection during conflict. Compatify's test is grounded in Martin's Humor Styles Questionnaire. It is science-informed self-reflection, not a clinical evaluation.
What this cannot tell you
A result describes how you use humour as you report it. It cannot tell you how your partner hears your jokes, whether your relationship will last, or whether a difference in humour is a minor quirk or a real source of hurt. Plenty of couples with very different senses of humour do well, because they respect each other's. And humour cannot fix what it is covering. If jokes are being used to belittle, humiliate or control a partner, that is not a humour style, and it deserves to be taken seriously. In Australia, 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732 offers confidential support around the clock.
Common questions
- What are the four humor styles?
- Affiliative humour, which builds connection with others; self-enhancing humour, which helps you cope; aggressive humour, which targets others; and self-defeating humour, which puts yourself down to be liked. Rod Martin and colleagues described them in 2003.
- Is a sense of humour important in a relationship?
- Yes. A large meta-analysis found positive humour associated with higher relationship satisfaction. The strongest link was with humour a couple shares, rather than with how funny each person thinks they are on their own.
- Can a couple with different senses of humour work?
- Yes. Different tastes in comedy matter far less than whether each person's humour is kind toward the other. Respecting what your partner finds funny, and dropping jokes that hurt, counts for more than matching.
- Is teasing in a relationship healthy?
- Gentle teasing between people who trust each other can be affectionate. It stops being healthy when one person is always the target, when it touches sore spots, or when objections are dismissed as not being able to take a joke.
- What is affiliative humor?
- Affiliative humour is the use of jokes, banter and shared laughter to bring people closer and ease tension, without anyone being the butt of the joke. It is the style most closely linked to connection in relationships.
Sources
- Martin, R. A., Puhlik-Doris, P., Larsen, G., Gray, J. and Weir, K. (2003). Individual differences in uses of humor and their relation to psychological well-being: development of the Humor Styles Questionnaire. Journal of Research in Personality.
- Driver, J. L. and Gottman, J. M. (2004). Daily marital interactions and positive affect during marital conflict among newlywed couples. Family Process.
- Hall, J. A. (2017). Humor in romantic relationships: a meta-analysis. Personal Relationships.